New Paradise Cafe 126 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY11963 New Paradise Cafe serves new, American fare and is famous for its pot roast and mashed potatoes. It also serves steaks,…More seafood and pasta. An elegant bar draws a wine crowd. For dining on Friday and Saturday nights. please make a reservation. Visitors often recall when it was part-bookshop, but the bookshop stopped being a few years back.